Green analytical chemistry metrics

Principles of green analytical metrics. National environment method index. Application of GAC metrics. Complementary green analytical procedure index. Additive color model to analytical method evaluation. Examples of analytical eco-scale calculation.

Рубрика Экология и охрана природы
Вид дипломная работа
Язык английский
Дата добавления 27.11.2022
Размер файла 2,0 M

Отправить свою хорошую работу в базу знаний просто. Используйте форму, расположенную ниже

Студенты, аспиранты, молодые ученые, использующие базу знаний в своей учебе и работе, будут вам очень благодарны.

Step 8. Read the algorithm's outcomes: the final quantitative measure of the method's adequacy, i.e., the method brilliance (MB), its qualitative evaluation - the final color, and the CS values for each primary attribute (in the template worksheet they are also calculated automatically) Figure 13.

Figure 13 Evaluation of the volumetric titration method aimed at determination of acetic acid in vinegar (RSD, relative standard deviation; RE, relative error)

2.6 Examples of analytical Eco-Scale calculation

In this sub-section, we evaluate examples of analytical procedures for greenness using the analytical Eco-Scale. Example - determination the amount of Cu in brass sample:

Table 10

The penalty points (PPs) for Cu determination by titration in a brass sample

Reagents

Penalty points

HNO3: 10 mL

8

NH3(aq.): 2 mL

6

CH3COOH: 10 mL

2

KI: 2 g

0

Na2S2O3

0

Starch

0

KSCN: 2 g

1

?17

Instruments

Penalty points

Heater

2

Occupational hazard

3

Waste

8

?13

Total penalty points: 30

Analytical Eco-Scale total score: 70

3. Problems and solutions

3.1 Qualitative problems

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using NEMI tool:

For RP-HPLC method for olanzapine and metformin [27] ethanol and water were used as a mobile phase. The used mobile phase had a pH approximately 6.5. The generated waste was 14 g/run.

Solution

Ethanol and water are not estimated as PBT or hazardous waste in reference to EPA's Toxic Release Inventory and hazardous waste list. Mobile phase has pH = 6.5 and so it is not estimated as corrosive. The amount of waste is less than 50 g. As a result, NEMI pictogram would look like this:

Figure 14 NEMI pictogram for olanzapine and metformin

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using NEMI tool:

For micellar HPLC method for chlorpheniramine maleate [28] EtOH, 50 mM sodium dihydrogen phosphate and 30 mM sodium dodecyl sulfate were used as a mobile phase. The used mobile phase had a pH approximately 5. The generated waste was 1-10 g/run.

Solution

Ethanol, sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium dihydrogen phosphate are not estimated as PBT or hazardous waste in reference to EPA's Toxic Release Inventory and hazardous waste list. Mobile phase has pH = 5 and so it is not estimated as corrosive. The amount of waste is less than 50 g. As a result, NEMI pictogram would look like this:

Figure 15 NEMI pictogram for chlorpheniramine maleate

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using NEMI:

Analyses of neurotransmitters was performed using LC-MS method [29]. Chromatography technique: LC that coupled with electrospray tandem MS. No. of analytes: 2 analytes including (dopamine and tetrahydrobiopterin). Stationary phase: Sepax Polar-Imidazole (2.1x100 mm, i.d., 3 µm) column. Mobile phase: Isocratic, 10 mM NH4HCO2 in CH3CN/H2O (75:25, х/х, 300 µL/min). Flow rate: 0.3 mL min-1. Time of analysis: 5 min vii. Biological sample: mouse brain tissue.

Figure 16 NEMI pictogram for neurotransmitters

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using GAPI:

Analyses of ibuprofen was performed using HPLC method [30]. All needed characteristics of procedure are listed in the Table 11:

Table 11

Analyses of ibuprofen

Category

Analyses of ibuprofen

Collection (1)

At-line

Preservation (2)

None

Transport (3)

Required

Storage (4)

Under special conditions

Type of method:

Direct or indirect (5)

Extraction required

Scale of extraction (6)

Microextraction

Solvents/reagents used (7)

Solvent-free methods

Additional treatments (8)

Advanced treatment

Amount (9)

10-100 mL

Health Hazard (10)

1) Acetonitrile - 2

2) Water - 0

3) Ortho-phosphoric acid - 3

Safety hazard (11)

1) Acetonitrile - 3

2) Water

3) Ortho-phosphoric acid - 0

Energy (12)

HPLC consumes ? 1.5 kWh per sample

Occupational hazard (13)

HPLC analysis will be done in a closed environment, so the chance of occupational hazards is less

Waste (14)

1-10 mL

Waste treatment (15)

No treatment

Solution:

Figure17 GAPI pictogram for ibuprofen

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using GAPI:

Analyses of neurotransmitters was performed using LC-MS method [29]. All needed characteristics of procedure are listed in the Table 12:

Table 12

Analyses of neurotransmitters

Category

Analyses of neurotransmitters

Collection (1)

Offline (red)

Preservation (2)

None (green)

Transport (3)

None (green)

Storage (4)

None (green)

Type of method:

Direct or indirect (5)

Extraction required (red)

Scale of extraction (6)

Nano-extraction (green)

Solvents/reagents used (7)

Non-green solvents and reagents (red)

Additional treatments (8)

Simple treatment (yellow)

Amount (9)

10< mL (green)

Health Hazard (10)

NFPA = 2, moderate toxicity (yellow)

Safety hazard (11)

NFPA = 3, high flammability (yellow)

Energy (12)

>1.5 Kwh per sample (red

Occupational hazard (13)

Hermetic sealing of analytical process (green)

Waste (14)

1-10 mL (yellow)

Waste treatment (15)

Recycling possible (green)

Solution:

Figure 18 GAPI pictogram for neurotransmitters

3.3 Quantitative problems

Ш Assess the greenness using AGREE:

For the determination of Flibanserin [30] LC was used. In this method external sample preparation with reduced number of steps was used. Amount of sample is equal to 25 mg. Analytical device was located in-line. Sample preparation include 3 or fewer main stages (filtration, sonification). Method is not automated, but with miniaturized sample preparation, as well as derivatization agent is not used. There is no waste in the method and number of analytes determined in single run is equal to 4, the time needed for one run 3 minutes. In this method all reagents from biobased resources and they are not toxic, but one reagent is highly flammable.

Solution:

Principle 1. The procedure involves external sample treatment with reduced number of steps. > 0.3

Principle 2. 0.025 g of soil sample is needed. > -0.142 ln (0,025) + 0,65 = 1

Principle 3. The measurement is in-line. > 1

Principle 4 the procedure involves 3 distinct steps. > 1

Principle 5. The procedure is not automated but miniaturized. > 0.5

Principle 6. No derivatization agents are involved in the analysis. > 1

Principle 7. No waste > 0

Principle 8. Four analytes are determined in a single run and the sample throughput is ? 20 samples h?1. · > 1

Principle 9. LC is the most energy demanding analytical technique. > 0.5

Principle 10. All reagents can be from bio-based sources. > 1

Principle 11. Toxic solvents are not used > 1

Principle 12. Acetone is considered highly flammable. > 0.8

Figure 19 AGREE pictogram for Flibanserin

Ш Assess the greenness using AGREE:

For the determination of Glibenclamide [31] LC was used. In this method at-line was used. Amount of sample is equal to 0.010 ml. Analytical device was located on-line. Sample preparation include 3 or fewer main stages. Method is semi-automated with miniaturized sample preparation, as well as derivatization agent is not used. Number of wastes is equal to 5 ml and number of analytes determined in single run is equal to 1, the time needed for one run 5 minutes. In this method all reagents from biobased resources and they are not toxic, but one reagent is highly flammable.

Solution:

Principle 1. At-line sample preparation. > 0.3

Principle 2. 0.010 ml of sample sample is needed. > -0.142 ln (0,010) + 0,65 = 1

Principle 3. The measurement is on-line. > 0.66

Principle 4 The procedure involves 3 distinct steps. > 1

Principle 5. The procedure is semi-automated and miniaturized. > 0.75

Principle 6. No derivatization agents are involved in the analysis. > 1

Principle 7. 5 ml of wastes. > -0,134 · ln (5) +0,6965 = 0.48

Principle 8. One analyte is determined in a single run and the sample throughput is ? 12 samples h?1. · > 0.55

Principle 9. LC is the most energy demanding analytical technique. > 0.5

Principle 10. Some reagents are from bio-based sources. > 0.5

Principle 11. The procedure includes 5 ml of toxic solvents > 0.5

Principle 12. Methanol is considered highly flammable. > 0.8

Figure 20 AGREE pictogram for Glibenclamide

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using Eco-scale (electrogravimetric Cu determination in a brass sample) [5]:

Weighing 1 mg of brass sample. Addition of 25 mL of HNO3 (1:1); heating until the sample dissolves. Addition of: distilled water, NH3(aq), 2 mL of H2SO4, 2 g of NH4NO3. Electrolysis at a temperature of 80oC; amperage: 1-2 A; voltage: 2 V; time: 2 hours; Pt electrodes Table 13:

Table 13

The penalty points (PPs) for electrogravimetric Cu determination in a brass sample

Reagents

Penalty points

HNO3: 10 mL

8

NH3(aq.)

6

H2SO4: 2 mL

2

NH4NO3:2g

1

?17

Instruments

Penalty points

Heater

2

Occupational hazard

3

Waste

5

?15

Total penalty points: 27

Analytical Eco-Scale total score: 73

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using Eco-scale (for PCB determination in sewage sludge by GC-MS) [5]:

Sampling. Sample lyophilization (temperature: -50oC, pressure: 0,025 mbar). Mixing of 2 g of sample with 1,5 g of activated Cu and 4,5 g of anhydrous Na2SO4; shaking; spiking with internal standard (13C). Addition of activated basic Al2O3; accelerated solvent extraction (pressure: 1500 psi, temperature: 125oC, solvent: n-hexane-acetone 1:1, preheating time: 1 min, heating time: 6 min, static time: 5 min). Addition of 1 mL of isooctane to the extract; evaporation to approx, 1 mL with a rotary evaporator; SPE column with acidic silica (40% w/w) and a 0,5 cm thick layer of anhydrous Na2SO4; solvent: n-hexane (20 mL for washing the bed and 25 mL for elution); addition of 1 mL of isooctane; evaporation to approx. 1 mL with a rotary evaporator, evaporation to approx 0,5 mL under N2 stream. Analysis by GC-MS; Injector type: PTV - splitless, 85oC (0,1 min), 4oC/min to 270oC (3 min), 2oC/min to 350oC (15 min); injected volume: 2 µL, injector temperature: 65oC, carrier gas type and linear velocity: He, 1,5 mL/min; column: fused silica, 60 m, 0,25 mm i.d., stationary phase: 50% phenyl-methylpolysiloxane; film thickness: 0,25 µm (J&W, Db17); temperature program: from 60oC (2 min), 20oC/min to 200oC (1 min), 4oC/min to 280oC (15 min), MSD conditions: GC-MS interface: direct with temperature 250oC, MS source: electron impact with temperature 180oC; MS acquiring in SIM mode; m/z 256, 258, 268, 270, 290, 292, 302, 304, 326, 328, 340, 360, 362, 372, 374, 394, 396, 406, 408; qualitative analysis: MS peak area, average response factor of different PCBs relative to icotopically labelled PCBs Table 14.

Table 14

The penalty points (PPs) for PCB determination in sewage sludge by GC-MS

Reagents

Penalty points

Cu powder: 1.5 g

1

HCl: 2 mL

3

Na2SO4 (drying agent): 4.5 g + 1 g

0

Isotopically labeled PCBs standard mixture

4

Activated Al2O3:1g

0

n-Hexane: 15 mL + 45 mL

16

Acetone: 15 mL

8

Isooctane: 2 mL

8

Acidic silica (98% of H2SO4: 20 mL)

4

PCBs standard solution

4

?48

Instruments

Penalty points

Sampler

1

Transport

1

Freeze-drying instrument (50oC, 0.025 mbar)

2

ASE extractor (1500 hPa, 125oC)

2

Rotary evaporator

2

Oven (for acidic silica preparation)

2

GC-MS

3

Occupational hazard

0

Waste

4

?17

Total penalty points: 65

Analytical Eco-Scale total score: 35

Ш Assess the greenness of procedure using Eco-scale (e for a determination of mercury in an animal tissue by cold-vapor atomic absorption spectrometry) [5]:

Sampling. Lyophilization, weighing of sample directly in ceramic boat. Additions of additives M and B. Inserting a ceramic boat into MA-2000 instrument and performance of the measurement Parameters set: concentration level: mode LOW or HIGH; temperature program: MODE2. Calculation of Hg concentration. Table 15.

Table 15

The penalty points (PPs) for Hg determination by CVAAS in an animal tissue

Reagents

Penalty points

Additives M and B

0

Hg standard solutions

2

?2

Instruments

Penalty points

Freeze-drying instrument

2

Hot-plate

2

Spectrometer

2

Occupational hazard

0

Waste

2

?8

Total penalty points: 10

Analytical Eco-Scale total score: 90

Conclusion

Each metrics has its own merits and demerits, which were well defined in Table 8. While each evaluation tool provides its unique conclusions about adopting the green metrics, these conclusions may vary, causing the analyst's decision-making process challenging. NEMI is a classical and simple evaluation tool for greenness assessment in analytical methods. However, despite its simplicity, NEMI does not cover all the green analytical principles, which is the main drawback in the adoption as an evaluation tool; apart from that, NEMI helps to select solvents that do not cover under the PBT list and makes the steps towards greenness. GAPI is the best available qualitative assessment tool that covers all the green analytical principles with three color coding, makes the assessment simple but due to its representation of 15 quadrants which makes it a little complex. Analytical Eco-Scale is a quantitative tool; The scores obtained with Analytical Eco-Scale are quantitative, but their calculation is based on qualitative pictograms. Further, biobased solvents such as ethanol have few penalty points, restricting the analysts to select ethanol as mobile phases in LC methods. Instead, Analytical Eco-Scale can help the analyst select the chemicals that have a less toxic effect (fewer pictograms) on the environment rather than having more pictograms. The subsequent flaw is in the amount of reagent used, which was approximate rather than accurate. AGREE metrics a practical, user-friendly software that covers GAC principles, and it works on the mode of Graphical User Interface (GUI). The outcomes do not often provide details around the structure of hazards, or including too general data about the evaluated analytical method may not be a more significant drawback than other metrics. Among all the other metrics available for green analytical evaluation tools, AGREE is among the top to cover all the nooks of GAC principles ultimately and provides weightage for the principles on which the users focus specifically.

Bibliography

1. Anastas, P.T. Green Chemistry and the Role of Analytical Methodology Development / P.T. Anastas // Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry. 1999. Vol. 29, № 3. P. 167-175.

2. Kirchhoff, M.M. Promoting sustainability through green chemistry / M.M. Kirchhoff // Resources, Conservation and Recycling. 2005. Vol. 44, № 3. P. 237-243.

3. Namiesnik, J. Pro-Ecological education: Chemical faculty of the Technical University of Gdaсsk, Poland / J. Namiesnik // Environmental Science and Pollution Research. 1999. Vol. 6, № 4. P. 243-244.

4. Keith, L.H. Gron, L.U. & Young, J.L. Green Analytical Methodologies / L.H. Keith, L.U. Gron, J.L. Young // Chemical Reviews. 2007. Vol. 107, № 6. P. 2695-2708.

5. Gaіuszka, A. et al. Analytical Eco-Scale for assessing the greenness of analytical procedures / A. Gaіuszka et al. // TrAC Trends in Analytical Chemistry. 2012. Vol. 37, - P. 61-72.

6. Pena-Pereira, F. Wojnowski, W. & Tobiszewski, M. AGREE--Analytical GREEnness Metric Approach and Software / F. Pena-Pereira, W. Wojnowski, M. Tobiszewski // Analytical Chemistry. 2020. Vol. 92, № 14. P. 10076-10082.

7. Pіotka-Wasylka, J. A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical procedure: Green Analytical Procedure Index / J. Pіotka-Wasylka // Talanta. 2018. Vol. 181, - P. 204-209.

8. http://www.epa.gov/tri/chemical/

9. https://www.undp.org/sustainable-development-goals

10. Valcarcel Cases, M. Principles of Analytical Chemistry: a Textbook / M. Valcarcel Cases. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2000..

11. Green Chemistry Metrics / M. Espino [et al.] // Comprehensive Foodomics. Elsevier, 2021. P. 825-833.

12. Comparative study of four greenness assessment tools for selection of greenest analytical method for assay of hyoscine N -butyl bromide / M. Gamal [et al.] // Anal. Methods. 2021. Vol. 13, № 3. P. 369-380.

13. O. G. Bhusnure, Life Cycle Assessment (Lca) Approach To Analytical Method Development: A Review, World J. Pharm. Pharm. Sci., 2015, 4, 933.

14. Van Aken, K. EcoScale, a semi-quantitative tool to select an organic preparation based on economical and ecological parameters / K. Van Aken, L. Strekowski, L. Patiny // Beilstein J. Org. Chem. 2006. Vol. 2.

15. Towards a holistic approach to metrics for the 21st century pharmaceutical industry / C.R. McElroy [et al.] // Green Chem. 2015. Vol. 17, № 5. P. 3111-3121.

16. Nowak, P.M. What Color Is Your Method? Adaptation of the RGB Additive Color Model to Analytical Method Evaluation / P.M. Nowak, P. Koњcielniak // Anal. Chem. 2019. Vol. 91, № 16. P. 10343-10352.

17. The case for the use of unrefined natural reagents in analytical chemistry--A green chemical perspective / K. Grudpan [et al.] // Anal. Methods. 2010. Vol. 2, № 11. P. 1651.

18. United Nations, Globally Harmonized System of Classification and Labeling of Chemicals (GHS, Rev. 4), United Nations, New York, USA, 2011

19. D. Raynie, J.L. Driver, Green assessment of chemical methods, 13th Green Chem. Eng. Conf., Washington, DC, USA, 2009.

20. Yu, C. Novel combined stir bar sorptive extraction coupled with ultrasonic assisted extraction for the determination of brominated flame retardants in environmental samples using high performance liquid chromatography / C. Yu, B. Hu // Journal of Chromatography A. 2007. Vol. 1160, № 1-2. P. 71-80.

21. Evaluation of Soxhlet extraction, accelerated solvent extraction and microwave-assisted extraction for the determination of polychlorinated biphenyls and polybrominated diphenyl ethers in soil and fish samples / P. Wang [et al.] // Analytica Chimica Acta. 2010. Vol. 663, № 1. P. 43-48.

22. Applying green analytical chemistry (GAC) for development of stability indicating HPLC method for determining clonazepam and its related substances in pharmaceutical formulations and calculating uncertainty / A.B. Eldin [et al.] // Arabian Journal of Chemistry. 2019. Vol. 12, № 7. P. 1212-1218.

23. A rapid and sensitive stability-indicating green RP-HPTLC method for the quantitation of flibanserin compared to green NP-HPTLC method: Validation studies and greenness assessment / A.I. Foudah [et al.] // Microchemical Journal. 2021. Vol. 164 - P. 105960.

24. Magnetic nanoparticle-assisted in situ ionic liquid dispersive liquid-liquid microextraction of pyrethroid pesticides in urine samples / X. Li [et al.] // Microchemical Journal. 2020. Vol. 159 - P. 105350.

25. Jouyban, A. Dispersive liquid-liquid microextraction based on solidification of deep eutectic solvent droplets for analysis of pesticides in farmer urine and plasma by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry / A. Jouyban, M.A. Farajzadeh, M.R. Afshar Mogaddam // Journal of Chromatography B. 2019. Vol. 1124 - P. 114-121.

26. Evaluation of layered double hydroxide/graphene hybrid as a sorbent in membrane-protected stir-bar supported micro-solid-phase extraction for determination of organochlorine pesticides in urine samples / M. Sajid [et al.] // Journal of Chromatography A. 2017. Vol. 1489 - P. 1-8.

27. Emam, A.A. et al. Ecofriendly chromatographic methods for determination of co-prescribed drugs, olanzapine and metformin, in rat plasma / A.A. Emam et al. // Bioanalysis. 2020. Vol. 12, № 9. P. 597-613.

28. Foudah, A.I. et al. A rapid and sensitive stability-indicating green RP-HPTLC method for the quantitation of flibanserin compared to green NP-HPTLC method: Validation studies and greenness assessment / A.I. Foudah et al. // Microchemical Journal. 2021. Vol. 164, - P. 105960.

29. Application of Three Ecological Assessment Tools in Examining Chromatographic Methods for the Green Analysis of a Mixture of Dopamine, Serotonin, Glutamate and GABA: A Comparative Study / A.H. Almalki [et al.] // Molecules. 2021. Vol. 26, № 18. P. 5436.

30. Hamdy, M.M.A. & Abdel Moneim, M.M. HPLC-fluorescence detection for assay of tramadol binary mixtures with ibuprofen or chlorzoxazone in tablets and plasma: Analytical Eco-Scale and GAPI tools for green assessment / M.M.A. Hamdy, M.M. Abdel Moneim // Acta Chromatographica. 2021. Vol. 34, № 2. P. 185-196.

31. Haq, N. et al. Rapid Analysis of Glibenclamide Using an Environmentally Benign Stability-Indicating RP-HPLC Method / N. Haq et al. // Iranian Journal of Pharmaceutical Research. 2014. Vol. 13, № 3.

Размещено на Allbest.ru


Подобные документы

  • Международные конвенции и соглашения, посвященные проблемам охраны окружающей природной среды. Участие России в международном сотрудничестве. Общественные организации в области охраны окружающей среды. Green peace. Всемирный фонд охраны дикой природы.

    реферат [26,3 K], добавлен 14.03.2004

  • Air pollution. Deforestation. Acid rain. The "Green House Effect". Water pollution. Toxic waste pollution. Environmental movements. Rates of deforestation. Carbon Dioxide Emissions per Units of Economic Output. Increase of global surface temperature.

    курсовая работа [51,8 K], добавлен 13.05.2005

  • Problem of contamination of nature in connection with activity of man. Air's and water's pollution. Garbage as the main reason of pollution of cities. Influence of radiating radiations on people and animals. Value of preservation of the environment.

    презентация [1,4 M], добавлен 13.12.2011

  • Environmental standard. Economic regulation of protection environment. The prices for the energy, existing ecological standards and more effective productions. The ecological nature of Technology of mass-media and the equipment of technological processes.

    реферат [12,8 K], добавлен 18.03.2009

  • Ecology as the scientific study of the relation of living organisms to each other and their surroundings. Overuse of pesticides. Climate change. Urban development. Scale rise in the average temperature of the Earth's climate. Genetically modified foods.

    презентация [3,3 M], добавлен 17.03.2017

  • Concept and evaluation of the significance of garbage collection for the urban economy, maintaining its beneficial environmental climate and clean air. Investigation of the major environmental problems in Almaty. Need for waste sorting and recycling.

    презентация [2,4 M], добавлен 29.04.2014

  • Description the introductions between man and nature, polluting of the air, oceans. Analyzes problems of cities: the wastes from factories, chemical plants, electric and atomic power stations. Studying the antipollution campaigns of car corporation’s.

    эссе [10,1 K], добавлен 21.03.2012

  • Causes of oceanic noise pollution. Evaluation of the negative impact of noise on the life of a different nature of organisms living in the ocean. The propagation direction and the degree of noise produced by a variety of water vessels in the ocean.

    презентация [2,5 M], добавлен 28.04.2015

  • Global ecological crisis. Pollution of atmosphere. The preservation of the biosphere of an ozone layer of the atmosphere absorbing ultra-violet radiation harmful for live oragnizm of the Sun. Reduction of number of the woods. Exhaustion of rainforests.

    презентация [368,2 K], добавлен 03.10.2012

  • Explanation of the causes of global warming. Power point presentation investigating the following question. Explanation of the effects of global warming in both MEDCs and LEDCs. Evaluation of the different viewpoints held about global warming by MEDCs.

    презентация [683,5 K], добавлен 21.02.2011

Работы в архивах красиво оформлены согласно требованиям ВУЗов и содержат рисунки, диаграммы, формулы и т.д.
PPT, PPTX и PDF-файлы представлены только в архивах.
Рекомендуем скачать работу.