. , , . pa . paooe ooee ooo appaoo cya.

28.10.2014
60,9 K

. ,

, , , , .

http://www.allbest.ru/

1.

1.1

1.2

2.

2.1

2.2

Cco opax ao cooao epayp

, .

. 46 . , . : . , . -- , .

2002 . ( - ) . , , - .

. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , . .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. . , - , .

.

:

- ;

- ;

- .

, .

, .

. (, , ), (-, -, , -, - ).

- : , , , , - .

.

, .

. , , , , .

1.

1.1

y acaooo (a. cassatio - oea, yoee ) oaoa poccco paaco cyopooce opaoa epo cyeo peop 1864 . ocoo acoa paycoo cyopooceoo aooaeca. Copeea acca apoac oya aoee aoeoe pae o pa. XVI . cyecoaa ye ceaa aoa opoecoy coey a contrarits et nullits (poopeoc eeceoc, ooc) cyex pee. opoacy 1667 . acca opeeec a opo oe pee, apyax opoac . pao acca o apyo opoeco ac cocao y oee opoecoo coea (conseil des parties) . . 2 ., . . [] / .. . - .: , 2013. - . 11..

Opaaop cyeo peop 1864 . epe oeeceo cop opa ae a aooaeco o paocy a a cpoy ccey c ype aooepoc, ocpoey cpoo cooec c e eoc, oea epeca oeca. ae paecyeo ceaa, oop yepac cyee yca, oopoc: oop Pocc cy cop, pa, oc pa cex oax, oc cyey ac, a e aeay caocoeoc ooe yep apoe yaee aoy, e oeo eooo oeceoe aococoe oopoe oo oco pyooee ec cex aoo o ceo o eo . : .. : [] / .. // . - 2012. - 8. - . 36.. Coaco cay paacoo cyopooca [] / . .. - 2- ., . - .: , 2013. - . 318. poepa cyex ao, cyx aoy cy, a ooea a paac eapae paecyeo Ceaa, c epxo accao cyo cex cyex opao ocyapca.

Coepae cyeo ac paecyeo Ceaa a accaooo cya xapaepoaoc cey epa: o-epx, o oa e pea eo o cyecy , o-opx, e paccapa a ea. accao cy, coceo, paccapa e eo, a cyeoe peee, c, pao oo eceo c o pe coe op ecyeo aooaeca. a o poeeo eoe papaee ey aeo accao cocoa oaoa cyex pee. Cy aeoo ca (poe Ce Cyee aa) poep oayee cyee a, e cye aoy cy, o py oo ae, .e. a pee x aooc oocoaoc, peaaee acca cocoo ocyece aa: o-epx, epecopa cyx cy cyex pee a pee x cooec opa poeccyaoo aepaoo paa , o-opx, oecee eoopaoo oa pee aoa p opae paocy eco cya a eppop ce Pocc.

accaoe ooo o ea poo c pa pyco, Oco aeco cye aaa, a peyae ee paacoo cyopooca 1889 . accaoe ao o ea, oope paee ocy ec opoc cy, ca oocc ee yepcx pcyc .. . . - . 36..

eo, copec o eeoc cya accaoo ca opeooo Pocc ceecye, o cyecoae cyeo ccee opeooo Pocc cya co, oo acca epo apax coao-ooecx oecx peopaoa ec e.

coeco pae acca pecaa coo ocoo aopa a cyeo eeoc ecox cyo, oox aoee cpo cpa oyee cya o oecea eoopaoe ooe peee aoo cya. ocyapce appa o ocee y ccee ypae apo xoco o ox. C oo copo, o c opao ocyapceoo ypae, aee oo po ooo cepe xocex ooe (a pao p opax ao), , c pyo copo, papea oae ao cepe cop ey pep. Oopeeo ecoaa ccea eocex appae, oeceaa papeee xocex copo ey pep paax ooo cepca eoca. e, o coeca cop appaoo poecca xapaepoaac a cyoc epa, a: ocyce aeoo cce eepaa accaox ca, coaa oooc ya ece yco, oeaa oooc oo yac aepecoax acea accaooo cya. o a ao pa ocee coeco ay pa .. : [] / .. // . - 2012. - 121. - . 265..

1991 . a papaoaa oe cyeo peop Poccco eepa 24.10.1991 1801-1 " " // . - 1991. - 44. - . 1435.. Peyao peop oac ooecoo paocy cao pepaee opao ocappaa appae cy, oope caoc epa eeo exae papee oo oac pepaeco eeoc. a coaa ooc eaca o cyo oe pc ccea appax cyo, oaea coce c cye opao.

A P 1992 . aece accaoo paccapa cyey ca, a oopy oaaac poepa aooc oocoaoc e cyx aoy cy pee appaoo cya o aoa , yacyx ee, poeca poypopa. cyae oa accaoo ao (poeca) peee, ec oo e o oeeo eeo, cyao aoy cy oce x paccope accaoo ca. accaoa ca e a caa ooa ao poeca poepa oayeoe peee oo oee, o ec a oaoao, a eoaoao ac. Paccapa accaoy aoy (poec) a peee appa cy, p peee, ec e a opaoaa oe o poepe accaoo ope aooc oocoaoc pee, e cyx aoy cy. p ocyc appao cye oe accaoa aoa (poec) oaac c Appa Cy P (AC P) epe appa cy, p peee.

a opao, yoao poeccyao cy accaoo ca peca coo ae, ocoy e xapaepe ep aoo cocoa poep oayex cyex ao. paoa ppoa o A P 1992 . accaoo ca, o-epx, e ooa oop o occaoe cya acca eo acceco oa, o e, ao o cyecoa opeooo Pocc, a, o-opx, pecoaa oppoa copeeo cce opo a aooc oocoaoc cyex ao.

pe 12 eap 1993 . ocy P, oppoae ooo paacoo aooaeca, a ae o yopoa appax cyo aece opao paocy, .. opae, opee eoxooc peoppoa cce appax cyo. C yeo oo AC P ooo poe eepaoo ocyooo aoa O appax cyax Poccco eepa 28.04.1995 1- (. 06.12.2011) " " // . - 1995. - 18. - . 1589; 2011. - 50. - . 7334. - . A P 1995 . C 1 1995 . aooaee a cy cy.

cy accaooo pooca appao poecce o e, ao o apee A P 1995 . oy aeee pae ecye A P, oaec o paox op accaooo epecopa. opae poepo aooc oaoax cyex ao, .e. cooec pee, ocaoe, opeee cyo ecox ca opa aepaoo poeccyaoo paa. o aoae epe oy o pa accaoy ccey epecopa, e oycay poep aecx ocoec ea (ycaoee x paccapaoc a cea pepoaa cyo 1- aeoo ca) .. [] / .. // . - 2009. - 3. - . 27. .

C pyo copo, cocae ooo appaoo cya accaoo ca aooae ape pao e peee cya epo ca ocaoee aeoo ca, oe pe cyee a p ooe peee e apae ea a ooe paccopee. o e coceo acceco acca, o pcye peooy cocoy epecopa, xapaepoy pa epoecx cpa (epa, Acp ..), a ae oeeceoo paacoo poecca .. : . . ... [] / .. . - , 2007. - . 19..

aoc apeeoo A P cya acca oeeceoo poeccyaoo aooaeca aaec o, o poeypa accaooo epecopa (oaeoo oye accaooo pooca o aoe aepecoaoo a) acaec ceo cyex ao, cyx aoy cy oeax coe. o ooe accaooe pooco appao poecce aoae epecop ope aopa. Coeae ecye cye acca pao, pcyx pa ccea epecopa, ocaoo cee ycoe coepae cooecyx poeccyax op, ece c e o pae aaoy cyy oe oooc, oopx e e cce epecopa. pyoe ecoeoe peyeco accaooo epecopa appao poecce cao c cyoycpoce aceo aaec pacpocpae pc appax cyo opya a eppop ecox cyeo P, o cococye ypee epa cyeo ac paec cae oooc aoo-o ecoo a cyey eeoc .. [] / .. // . - 2013. - 7. - . 11..

a, cop pocccoo, a ae coecoo occoecoo cyopooca ao oepae aooepoc aoec oo paa: coao-oece ooece peopaoa c eeoc ey a coo ee paoo cyeo cceax, peopee x aoee cyecee xapaepc. a o o peea peoppoa pocccoo oeca 60--70-x . XIX ., oa ce a oeo peocoo paa oceoa peop cyoycpoca cyopooca. ao e oceoaeoc o peoppoae copeeo poccco cyeo cce, a occey appax cyo.

1.2 oe aee accaooo epecopa cyex ao

cooec c . 1 c. 45 ocy P (aee - ocy) aoy apapyec ocyapcea aa pa coo eoea paaa Poccco eepa, a coaco . 1 c. 46 ocy - cyea aa eo pa coo. ocyoe op oaa, o Pocccoe ocyapco apapoao cyey ay aox pa epeco, .. o ea, oeoce . o e cea o pocxo peyae p cyeoo aa appa cyo 1- ca. eoo a cpee 15 % cyae oayc .. [] / .. , .. . - 4- . - ., 2013. - . 10..

accaooe pooco -- paopee appaoo poecca, cyoc oopo aaec poepe eepa appa cya opyo aooc cyx aoy cy pee, ocaoe, opeee appax cyo cyeo P. acca - coco epecopa cyex ao appax cyo, p oopo ocyecec poepa aooc oocoaoc pee opeee cyo accaoo ca. pooco accaoo ca ec caocoeo ac appaoo poecca.

paoo eop poecca aea y acca paccapaac a eeoc o poepe cooec aoy cyex ao, px o cyecy aepao-paooo copa. opeeoe occee yoaoo aae accaooo opo ocaoo ayao ycox paooo ocyapca, oecee ooe (oaa ac) o axoc ococ paooo o. Oeceee epxoeca aoa, ypeee paoopa, o ce cepe oo, ca c peaae ooe, p oopo peya paopeeo eeoc cya o ypeypoa oecex ooe ye aoe cee cooecoa oe aooae, oepoao paox opax .. () , [] / .. // . - 2013. - 1 (43). - . 165..

Ca accaooo pooca appao poecce ae a:

1. oyee accaooo pooca;

2. oooa paccope accaoo ao;

3. cyeoe papaeco o accaoo aoe .. [] / .. // . - 2010. - 3. - . 14..

poeccyaa e acca appao poecce, oe o x cocoo epecopa, o, pee ceo, poepa aooc cyex ao e ycaoe ox ocoec ea (o ooo cye aeoo ca) .. , // [] / . . - .: , 2008. - . 121..

cyea accaooo epecopa oo , yacyx ee, oece a, e peee yac ee, o paax oaocx oopx p oayee cyee a.

Oea accaooo epecopa c ceo cyee a, cye aoy cy.

Cy accaooo pooca appao poecce xapaepy pa: o cocoo epecopa cyex ao, cyx aoy cy; ocyecec cea eo cyeo cce - eepa appa cya opyo; poeccyaa aaa - poepa aooc cyex ao; peeo c cyee a, cye aoy cy; eoxooe ocoae oye accaooo pooca - accaoa aoa a, aeeoo pao accaooo oaoa.

Paccop pep. OOO Cpoea oa PeCpoop opaoc Appa cy eepoco oac c co OOO Aaap. eo paccopeo ope ypoeoo pooca. Peee Appaoo cya eepoco oac o 26.12.2012, ocae e ee ocaoee Ceoo appaoo aeooo cya o 19.03.2013, c yoeope aco. OOO Aaap, e coacc c p o ey cye aa, opaoc eepa appa cy aao-Cpcoo opya c accaoo aoo. cooec c . 3 c. 229 A P peee o peyaa paccope ea ope ypoeoo pooca oe oaoao cpo, e pea 10 e co eo p, appa cy aeoo ca. o peee, ec oo o peeo paccope appao cye aeoo ca ec appa cy aeoo ca oaa occaoe poyeoo cpoa oa aeoo ao, ocaoee appaoo cya aeoo ca, oy oaoa appa cy accaoo ca o ocoa, peycope . 4 c. 288 A P. .. opa A P ope accaooo cyopooca peycopea oooc poep aooc eaax cyex ao ac ocoa, peycopex . 4 c. 288 A P, p ocyc accaoo aoe cc a ae ocoa, accaoa aoa oe opae peeo . 1 . 1 c. 281 A P - 12.04.2013 27-19625/2012 // . .: -..

eoope pa accaooo pooca appao poecce cyeceo oa a cy o ooeoo paaco poecce. a, peeo acca paaco poecce c cyee a, e cye aoy cy. Cy accaoo ca oe pa oe oaaeca ycaaa cyecee ocoeca ea, ocyece poepy a aooc, a oocoaoc oaoax ao. paacoy poeccy e coce o cyeoo opya cya accaoo ca a ceaoo ea cyeo cce, accao epecop ocyecec eco cyo .. . . - . 15..

ocoy cy accaoo ca appao poecce e pae ycaaa oe ocoeca ea, ey peocaeo oooe apa eo a ooe paccopee p oapye ecooec oo cya, coepaxc pee, ocaoe, aec ocoeca ea, ycaoe cya epo aeoo ca, ec ee oaaeca.

eepae appae cy opyo coa peaae ceo ocyece y accaooo epecopa oaoax cyex ao, peyao ocyece o y, oo oce oe e paocy, a apyeoo paa, ec ycaoee a eppop cyeoo opya eoopao cyeo pa, oppyeo c Appa Cyo P. cooec co c. 24 o appax cyax, ccee appax cyo P opaoao ec cyo opyo, a oopx ocyece co pc a eppop cooecyeo opya (c. poee 1). eepa appa cya opyo 2012 . paccopeo 88 306 e. o a 8,9% oe, e a po oe epo 2012 . // [ ] .

Coae eepax appax cyo opyo peopeeeo eoxooc ypee aooc eeoc appax cyo apa a pa opaa paa-pepaee, oecee eoopaoo apae cyeo pa oo cooec c peoa aooaeca. y accaoo ca appao poecce o o c Appa Cy P pey appax cyo cyeo P, o a ceecye poa paa, oee eopao ec aa cyea ccea, oopa coco e eee, e 3-x ee .. . . - . 12.. o pa coa appae cy opyo.

Co oe, oao, o p opeee opyo yaac eppop po pacooex cyeo P e yea ax-o aopo. ece c e, Pocc ee cac eec oaa copec coxc ooecx peoo, o aex aopo opaoa oopx ca ooo-xocee c, a ae, o e eee ao, pacope c eppop. peeax x eppop eee e paac xocee c pep, coac opeeea ooc e oo eppop, o acee. Oao coec ooece peo e ca eppope opyo accaox appax cyo. Ee oee cepe eocao opaoa appax opyo oc opeeee eca ocooo pea eepax appax cyo opyo. xo oce coe eca axoe appax cyo opyo pa epo, yoeop peoa pacopx ce, o ax, a Ceepo-aaco, aao-Cpco epao opyax eca axoe cyo pa eyao .. . . - . 15..

accaoe ao a pee o ae o pcye oeca a apyee paa a cyopooco pay cpo paccapac ope accaooo pooca e e cyo o cocae cye (. 2 c. 274 A P). opa eea c c pe eepaoo aoa o 30.04.2010 68- O oeca a apyee paa a cyopooco pay cpo paa a coee cyeoo aa pay cpo . - 04.05.2010. . : 30, 64 23.12.2010 " , " // . - 2011. - 2; 25.06.2010 140 " , 30.04.2010 N 69- " " " // . - 2010. - 9..

Coaco . 3 c. 274 A P, cy o eeya paa aece cya accaoo ca paccapae:

1) ea, paccopee aece cya epo ca;

2) ea o ae eeyax pa, paccopee appa cya cyeo P aece cya epo ca, appa aeo cya. eee aoo ooe oycoeo e, o p ao 06.12.2011 4- " " " " // . - 2011. - 50. - . 7334., peycapa coae cya o eeya paa 19.12.2012 // . - 2013. - 1(35).. Coae Cya o eeya paa ec peae a oee opeoc ae ocyece pa a peya eeyao eeoc.

eepaoe aeoe pepe Coooop opaoc Appa cy opoa oc c co peoa apoy aoepoy oecy Cooop o ocpoo pepae paoo oxpa coecoo oapoo aa 266687 Stoli Cranbery a eppop P ooe cex oapo ycy 32 33 acco eyapoo acca oapo ycy pecpa ao (Y), cece eo ecooa. Peee Appaoo cya opoa oc o 04.04.2013 coe peoa yoeope. ocaoee eoo appaoo aeooo cya o 08.07.2013 peee Appaoo cya opoa oc o 04.04.2013 oeeo, yoeope cox peoa oaao. e coacc c ocaoee eoo appaoo aeooo cya o 08.07.2013, Coooop opaoc c accaoo aoo, oopo poc ocaoee oe, a peee cya epo ca oca e ee. Coaco paoo o, oeo ocaoe peya AC P o 01.03.2011 14503/10, paooaae oa cooa apecppoa oap a a ycoe coxpae paa a eo. p o yaaoe ocaoee e coep cepax pepe opeee aepecoaoc a ocpoo pepae paoo oxpa ecoyeoo oapoo aa.

cooec c . 1 c. 288 A P ocoa ee oe pee, ocaoe appaoo cya epo aeoo ca c ecooece oo cya, coepaxc pee, ocaoe, aec ocoeca ea, ycaoe appa cyo epo aeoo ca, ec ee oaaeca, apyee o epaoe peee op aepaoo paa op poeccyaoo paa. Pyoocyc c.c. 286, 287, 289 A P, cy accaoo ca ocao: ocaoee eoo appaoo aeooo cya o 08.07.2013 o ey A40-169373/2012 oe, peee Appaoo cya opoa oc o 04.04.2013 o oy e ey oca ce 22.10.2013 40-169373/2012 // . .: -..

paooe ooee cya accaoo ca appao poecce, poe cyecex pao accaooo pooca, xapaepyec coepae aooaeo apeex ooo cya accaoo ca - eepaoo appaoo cya opya. Coepae ooo eco cao c cocao yaco poeccyaoo paoooe o accaooy epecopy appao poecce ( oop oo , yacyx ee, oece cy: cooecye cyee ca, a oopx oaoa, coceo appa cy accaoo ca) .. . . - . 122..

ooo appaoo cya accaoo ca oo pae a 2 aeop acoc o xapaepa aoec c py yaca poecca: a cyeo ca o ope ea; a cyeoo opaa. epa pya ooo eocpeceo caa c paccopee ea cye: poepe aooc cyex ao o ea, paccope cya epo aeoo ca; epecapae o o opc ocoeca pe cyee a; opaaec ocyo Cy P c apoco o poepe ocyooc aoa, peeoo oeaeo pee paccapaeo ee. o opo pye ooo cya accaoo ca a cyeoo opaa, e cax eocpeceo c paopeeo eeoc o opeoy ey, oece: yee ooee cyeo pa, oooa peoe o coepecoa aoo x opax ao, aa cyeo cac paoe eoopaoo oxoa pee aooaeca paccope copo.

Ceye oepy, o ec cyea eeoc eea, o o e oe e pec oeo cee eea cyeo ac. peco aye pao oeeo, o eoc cyeo ac poec epe ooee e cyeo cyopooca oeca ooe, o pee ceo paaec oep (o eoep) cyeo ac oece eo cyeo poecce acoc .. : . . ... [] / .. . - ., 2010. - . 5.. ee cy co peee eeo caoc ee (.e. pocxo eo eea) co ce ea oca coa ocec. poe oo, ya xoee Poccco eepa eoe epoecoe paooe pocpaco cepe a pa coo eoea, e ceye aa o eyapoo acee eoc. .. cae: pecoe ooee epoecx cyo paa aopo ca ccee cyo opeee ocooe ooee cya accaoo ca, opaee oopo oo paccapa a cepae ypex cpec paoo a .. . . - . 3..

a, pooco appao cye accaoo ca oaec e coo peoca ooe (oaa accaoo ao a cy aoy cy cye a peeax ycaoeoo aoo poeccyaoo cpoa), coo cea e, oope opeec poepo aooc oayeoo cyeoo aa (c. 288 A P), a ae eo oocoaoc (. 3 c. 287 A P). Appa poeccya pe eeoc cya accaoo ca - o ccea peyoo oec a poeccyae paoooe, oae ey eepa appa cyo opya cyea accaooo oaoa, apaee oo eae e - poepe aooc oaoax cyex ao; ccea, opeea yco ocyece opeoo paa a cyey ay ye oecee coo payoo ec cyeo accaooo oaoa coea c aepecoaoc peaa cyex pa c oeceoc a ecoee poeccyax oaoce paax eo paoo peaea eeoc appaoo cya accaoo ca.

aa 2. Peaa ooo cya accaoo ca appao poecce

2.1 poeccya opo accaooo pooca

oyee accaooo pooca - aa a poeyp accaooo epecopa, xoe oopoo cy paccapae oooc peaa paa a epecop cyeoo aa cye accaoo ca, cxo peca cooecyx poeccyax op . . 2 ., . . [] / .. . - . 341.. pao ocoae ( poo cce) oye pooca appao cye accaoo ca ec cooyoc poeccyax pecx ao (pec coca), c cyecoae oopx poeccyae op ca peaa aepecoa o paa accaooo oaoa. yo cce ocoae oye accaooo pooca - accaoa aoa, aoee oe ee pecoo cocaa ocoa oye accaooo epecopa ..

Coca eea ocoa oye accaooo pooca oo aa ceye pece a: ae accaoo ao; ae y ae ao cayca cyea epecopa - a, aeeoo pao accaooo oaoa; cyecoae oea epecopa - cyeoo aa, oeaeo accaooy epecopy (a cyee eo aoy cy); coee yco oaoa - peoa ope coepa accaoo ao, cpoa ee oa opae a occaoee poyeoo cpoa, opa oa ao.

Ocoae oye accaooo pooca ec aoa , yacyx ee: e ao -- e epecopa.

Ocoae accaooo epecopa ec apaee ea aopo cae accaooo epecopa, .e. o ycope cya aopo ca. Oao o cyae oye accaooo pooca eoxoo cooecyee opaee a, yacyeo ee, cy aopo ca.

Cyee a - oe accaooo epecopa o cooecoa pep:

1) accaoo ope oy oaoa:

a) pee appax cyo epo ca ocaoe appax cyo aeoo ca. poe cyex ao ceo Appaoo Cya P o epo ca, oope e oy peeo accaooo epecopa;

b) opeee (a cyee a) appaoo cya epo aeoo ca: ecee e oeoo cyeoo aa, cyax, oa oaoae aoo a opeee peycopeo A P, oa aoe opeeee pecye aeey e ea. cxo ce accaooo opo o opeeee, pecy aeey e ea, ceye oa e oo cyee a, oope apya poeccyae paa yaco copa, aa paccopee ea, o cyee a, eopaao yee aepae paa , yacyx ee. pecy aeey e ea oea epecopy accaoo ope ae ce e opeee, oope oeo coa yco p epaoo pee o cyecy copa;

c) oea accaooo epecopa oece cyee a ecox ca opeee o opae accaox ao, ecee cye accaoo ca eoo. Cy accaoo ca pae ae epecapa pye opeee, pe accaoo ca, o ce oea cocao, ec oaoae ax opeee peycopeo A P.

2) eoxooe coco cyex ao, oeax accaooy oaoa, -- cyee x aoy cy a oe p opeee o oye accaooo epecopa .. [] / .. // . - 2013. - 9. - . 29..

pao accaooo oaoa aee: copo; ae aepecoae a -- o ea ocooo pooca, o ea o ecocoeoc (apoce) x cyax, peycopex A P; pe a, poypop, ocyapcee opa, opa ecoo caoypae e opa, opaec appa cy c co ay epeco pyx cyax, peycopex A P; a, e yacoae ee, o paax oaocx oopx appa cy p cye a (pece a paae, ocyece pepaecy eeoc e opaoa pecoo a, ece a). C oea p poocy accaoo ao aae cye oyc paa ecy oaoc , yacyx ee, .e. popea paooe ooee , yacyx ee.

Opeeee AC oocoo opya o 21.03.2013 o ey A65-25639/2011 o pepaeo pooco o accaoo aoe appaoo ypaeo c c e, o o ee paccope o cyecy ycaoeo, o opeeee appaoo cya yepeo pooe coaee, pooco o ey o ecocoeoc oa pepaeo. Opeeee ocaeo e ee, ocoy aea oea opeee o yepe pooo coae oooee pooca o ey o apoce e ey occaoee cayce oypcoo ypaeo, ae e pae opaac c acoe accaoo aoo 21.03.2013 65-25639/2011 // . .: -..

pao opo oa e accaoo ao -- epe cy cyea P, p oaye cye a (c. 275 A P). aoa ocyae cy accaoo ca ece c eo, e oopoo paccopee ao eooo. apyee aoo paa oe oe cepee eae ocec ae: opaee accaoo ao, a ae eoooc occaoe cpoa accaooo oaoa, poyeoo o o pe, oopa cyeo pae aco e paec yaeo.

Cpo accaooo oaoa cocae a eca co cye aoy cy oaoaoo cyeoo aa. cyae poyca aoo cpoa eoopx peycopex aoo cyax o oe occaoe appa cyo accaoo ca (c. 276 A P). caoe A P ecec cpo, oyca occaoee cpoa accaooo oaoa, ec peceae e oe occaoe p eo poyce .., .. - [] / .. , .. // . - 2012. - 9. - . 91..

Opaee a, yacyeo ee, oo cooecoa opeee peoa, o ocy ocoae oye accaooo epecopa oaoaoo cyeoo aa. poeccyaoe aooaeco paccapae aece aoo opae accaoy aoy, o ope coepa cooecyy aoy. epee peoa ope coepa accaoo ao ec cepa (c. 277 A P). accaoa aoa oa ceo ope, coepa eoxoe cee pe ocaa o, oa aoy, eo ooo pecaee. accaoa aoa ae oe oaa ocpeco aoe op, paeeo a oao cae appaoo cya opaoo-eeoyaoo ce epe. poeypa p accaoo ao poocy appaoo cya ypeypoaa c. 278 A P, e yaao, o oo accaoa aoa, oaa c coee peoa, peex A P ee ope coepa, ec ocoae oye accaooo pooca.

cy ocae accaoo ao e e, apee c. 280 A P, pa oece oepaoc ocyoc paocy a ca accaooo epecopa, ooe ea opax pec peaa paa a accaooe oaoae.

Opeeee AC aao-Cpcoo opya o 16.11.2012 o ey A67-2394/2012 accaoa aoa appaoo ypaeo oa ocaea e e c c ocyce oaaec apae copoe o oyeo ya ocyapceo o. accaoa aoa opaea, .. e ycpae ocoeca, ocye ocoae ocae ee e e - 16.11.2012 67-2394/2012 // . .: -..

oce coepeeoo ycpae eocao ao aoa oe p poocy, caec oao oa paccopea o cyecy peycope c. 285 A P cpo, cce c ee epoaaoo ocye cy. e accaoa aoa opaaec oe opeeee cy o pay . 2 c. 281 A P, o o e ae ae oooc oa aoy oopo oe ope.

Paccop pep. yaoe yapoe pepe eoce opaoc Appa cy Pecy aopoca c co acpa opocoo ocee . aa yaoo paoa aac pao o oa oea opa oe eoe yeco, yaaoe pacope acpa o 19.09.2008 62/1. Opeeee cya o 22.09.2011 yac ee aece pex , e ax caocoex peoa ooceo peea copa, pee oeco c opaeo oeceoc eoce, paee eepao cy ocyapceo pecpa, aacpa apopa o Pecye aopoca. Opeeee cya o 26.12.2011 yepeo pooe coaee o 23.12.2011, aeoe ey co oeo. pooco o acoey ey pepaeo. Coe opocoo ocee . aa opac pacoo opya c accaoo aoo. ae ao yaae, o yepee pooo coae apye paa aoe epec opocoo ocee . aa, eee cpeca, eoxoe coe oaec acpa, a oe ae pooo coae e peycope ee, cyae oa aoeoc o pooy coae yy copa coao-ooece popa opocoo ocee, e ye ocaox cpec pee opoco ecoo ae. accaoo aoe Coe opocoo ocee . aa poc ae occao cpo oaoa opeee o 26.12.2011 o yepe pooo coae.

Coaco . 8 c. 141 A P opeeee o yepe pooo coae oe eeeoy coe oe oaoao appa cy accaoo ca eee eca co ece opeee. .., cpo oa accaoo ao a opeeee cya o 26.12.2011 ceae 26.01.2012. C paccapaeo accaoo aoo Coe opocoo ocee opac appa cy 04.12.2012, .e. c poyco cpoa a oaoae cyeoo aa ope accaooo pooca. cy . 2 c. 276 A P cpo oa accaoo ao, poye o pa, e ac o a, opaeoc c ao aoo, .. c c ocyce y eo cee o oayeo cyeo ae, o xoaacy yaaoo a oe occaoe appa cyo accaoo ca p yco, o xoaaco oao e oee e epe 6 ec. c cye aoy cy oayeoo cyeoo aa , ec xoaaco oao o, yaa c. 42 A P, co , oa o o yao oo o ya o apye eo pa aox epeco oaye cye ao. Coe opocoo ocee . aa e ec o, yacy ee. aeo xoaaco o occaoe poyeoo cpoa a oay accaoo ao, o xoaaco e opoao. C yeo oeoo yoeope xoaaca o occaoe poyeoo poeccyaoo cpoa ceye oaa. .. cyo accaoo ca oaao yoeope xoaaca o occaoe poyeoo cpoa a accaooe oaoae, accaoa aoa oe opay ae 19.12.2012 09-13699/12 07-11319/2011 // . .: -..

oyee accaooo pooca ocyecec ye ece opeee o p accaoo ao.

a ae ooo accaoo ao paccope appa cyo accaoo ca coepac eoxoe ec coa yco, oox pe ceay poeccyay aay accaooo epecopa oaoax cyex ao oc oe e paocy: eae , yacyx ee, o pee ece paccope accaoo ao ocpeco apae opeee; papeae xoaaca o oecee ca pocaoe coe oaoax ao; yae accaoy aoy aepa ea; pepaae pooco o accaoo aoe cyax, peycopex A P.

pocaoee coe oaoax cyex ao (opeee, pee ocaoe cya epo aeoo ca) coaco . 1 c. 283 A P ooo oo o xoaacy ae oce p ao poocy. Cy accaoo ca e oe o coe ae pocaaa coee cyex ao ecox ca.

oooa ea cyeoy papaecy appax cyax accaoo ca ocyecec o o paa, coepac . 14 A P, c yeo ocoeoce, peycopex . 35 A P 20.12.2006 65 // . - 2007. - 4..

opo paccope ea appa cyo accaoo ca ycaoe c. 284 A P. Appa cy accaoo ca paccapae eo cyeo acea oea cocao cye o paa paccope ea appa cyo epo ca, peycope A P, c ocoeoc, ycaoe . 35 A P, a cee cyae: cy o eeya paa a appa cy accaoo ca paccapae eo, paccopeoe aece cya epo ca, cyeo acea peyo oo cya o paa paccope ea appa cyo epo ca, peycope A P, c ocoeoc, ycaoe . 35 A P.

Cpo paccope accaoo ao coaco c. 285 A P e oe pea, o oey pay, 2 ec. c ocye accaoo ao ece c eo appa cy accaoo ca, a cpo a oooy ea paccope cyeoe papaeco accaoo ca. Oe: accaoo ca 2012 . c peee ycaoeoo cpoa paccopeo eee 1% e 2012 . // [ ] // http://www.arbitr.ru/..

Cyeoe aceae cye accaoo ca ycoo oo opae a p ac: oooey, paccopee ooo ao o cyecy, pe ocaoe cya accaoo ca . . - 5 ., . . [] / . . .. . - .: , 2012. - . 468..

oooeo ac peceaecy opae cyeoe aceae, oe, aoe eo oe paccope, o e aoe ooe aoo aa oyeo pooco, poepe y , ae y xc pecaee ooo a yace ee. ae oec coca cya peaec opoc o oox ooax, yacy cyeo acea a pacc poeccyae paa oaoc, paccapac aee xoaaca. oce papee exc xoaac, peceaecy opeee opo paccope ao.


  • . . . .

    [30,1 K], 12.04.2009

  • , . . , .

    [46,8 K], 02.03.2010

  • . . . .

    [43,5 K], 12.10.2010

  • . , . .

    [43,3 K], 06.10.2010

  • . . . . .

    [30,4 K], 19.09.2013

  • : . . . . .

    [30,2 K], 07.12.2013

  • , . , . .

    [38,2 K], 20.09.2011

, , ..
PPT, PPTX PDF- .
.